Old Tappan is one of the Pascack Valley’s most quietly accomplished boroughs, a community of about 5,900 residents that consistently ranks among the safest, wealthiest, and best-educated places in Bergen County. With an A+ ranked regional high school right in the borough, near-zero violent crime, a 90% homeownership rate, and a median household income approaching $200,000, Old Tappan is the kind of place where families who can live anywhere choose to stay.
As a Bergen County real estate specialist, I’ve helped families find homes across every municipality in the county. Here are the top five reasons Old Tappan keeps showing up on my clients’ shortlists.
1. An A+ Regional High School Right in the Borough
Old Tappan’s K-8 sending district feeds into Northern Valley Regional High School at Old Tappan, one of the top public high schools in New Jersey. Ranked A+ by Niche and #27 in the state by U.S. News, NV/Old Tappan posts a 98% graduation rate, average SAT scores of 1330, and more than 25 AP courses. The student-teacher ratio runs about 10:1, and the school has produced National Merit Scholars, state championship athletic teams, and one of the strongest STEM programs in Bergen County.
The K-8 district earns an A from Niche, with T. Baldwin Demarest Elementary and Charles DeWolf Middle School both earning strong marks for academics and teacher quality. Having a top-30 state-ranked high school in your own borough, not a neighboring town, is a distinction very few Bergen County communities can claim.
2. Near-Zero Crime and a #8 Safety Ranking Statewide
Old Tappan’s crime statistics are among the most impressive in Bergen County. Violent crime is effectively zero. The borough has recorded either zero or one violent crime in recent reporting years. Property crime runs well below national averages, and Old Tappan has been ranked the #8 safest city in New Jersey among municipalities with a population of 5,000 or more.
The borough’s layout contributes to the safety profile: predominantly single-family homes on generous lots, no major commercial corridors generating through-traffic, and a community where neighbors know each other. It’s the kind of place where kids still ride bikes around the neighborhood and families walk to the park after dinner without a second thought.
3. A Highly Educated, High-Income Community
Old Tappan’s demographics tell the story of a community that attracts accomplished families. The median household income sits around $199,000, among the highest in Bergen County. Approximately 77% of adults hold at least a bachelor’s degree, nearly double the national average. The homeownership rate is 90%, the unemployment rate stays below 3%, and the poverty rate is under 2%.
The population is notably diverse, roughly 51% White and 41% Asian, reflecting the borough’s appeal to families across backgrounds who prioritize education, safety, and community. This diversity shows up in the schools, in the local restaurants, and in the character of the borough itself.
4. Quick Access to Manhattan Without the Density
Old Tappan sits about 18 miles from the George Washington Bridge, roughly 21 minutes by car via Route 303 and the Palisades Interstate Parkway. While the borough doesn’t have its own train station, NJ Transit bus stops are accessible nearby, and the Westwood station on the Pascack Valley Line is a short drive away, offering direct service to Hoboken Terminal with connections to Manhattan.
For commuters who drive, the combination of easy GWB access and Old Tappan’s residential tranquility is a powerful draw. You’re close enough for a manageable commute but far enough that the city disappears completely when you pull into your driveway. The trade-off of no train station is offset by lower density, larger lots, and the peace that comes with being at the northern edge of the Pascack Valley.
5. Parks, Recreation, and Suburban Character Done Right
Old Tappan offers a recreation program and park system that punches above its weight. The borough’s parks include athletic fields, playgrounds, and open space that give families room to breathe. The Old Tappan Swim Club is a summer institution. Community events, from seasonal festivals to recreation-organized activities, create the kind of neighborhood connections that keep families rooted.
The housing stock is predominantly single-family homes: colonials, split-levels, and newer construction on tree-lined streets with generous setbacks. The median home price runs in the mid-$800,000s to low $900,000s, reflecting the premium for the schools, safety, and community profile. For buyers comparing across the northern Pascack Valley, Old Tappan delivers a combination of academic excellence, safety, and community character that’s hard to match at any price point.
Where to Eat in Old Tappan
Old Tappan’s dining scene reflects the borough’s character: diverse, quality-driven, and unpretentious. Along Old Tappan Road and the surrounding area, you’ll find a Mediterranean fine dining destination with a 4.7 on OpenTable, an authentic Neapolitan family-run Italian, a neighborhood pizza shop with a near-perfect rating, and a well-established Japanese sushi spot. For a borough of under 6,000 residents, the range is impressive.
Here are my four personal favorites, the places I recommend to every client who asks what daily life in Old Tappan is really like.
Aurora Ristorante
Aurora is Old Tappan’s fine dining anchor, a Mediterranean restaurant on Old Tappan Road that’s earned a 4.7 on OpenTable and a loyal following across Northern Bergen County. The menu draws from Italian and broader Mediterranean traditions, with an emphasis on fresh seafood, handmade pastas, and seasonal specials that rotate regularly. The wine list is thoughtfully curated, and the atmosphere strikes the right balance between polished and welcoming.
With strong ratings on Google and consistent praise from diners on Yelp, Aurora is the restaurant Old Tappan residents bring guests to when they want to impress, and the place they return to themselves when they want a genuinely excellent meal without driving 30 minutes.
Why locals love it: mediterranean fine dining with a 4.7 on OpenTable, right in Old Tappan. The seafood and handmade pastas are destination-worthy, and the ambiance makes every dinner feel like an occasion.
Bosfa Neapolitan Restaurant
Bosfa brings authentic Neapolitan cooking to Old Tappan, a family-run Italian restaurant that’s earned a 4.7 on Google with the kind of loyal following that only comes from years of consistent quality. The menu covers the full Italian repertoire, from wood-fired pizzas to classic pasta dishes to seafood, all prepared with the simplicity and freshness that defines Neapolitan tradition.
The family atmosphere is genuine. This isn’t a corporate restaurant playing at warmth. The staff knows regulars by name, the portions are generous, and the BYOB policy keeps the bill reasonable for the quality. For families in Old Tappan, Bosfa is the go-to neighborhood Italian.
Why locals love it: authentic Neapolitan cooking from a family that treats every guest like a regular. The 4.7 on Google is earned, and the BYOB format makes it an easy weeknight dinner or a Saturday celebration.
La Bona Pizza
La Bona is Old Tappan’s pizza institution, a neighborhood shop that’s built a near-perfect aggregate rating across review platforms (4.9 when you average Google, Yelp, and DoorDash scores). The menu goes beyond pizza to include Italian subs, calzones, pasta dishes, and salads, but the pizza is why people keep coming back. Thin crust, quality ingredients, and the kind of consistency that makes it the default answer to “where should we order from tonight?”
For a small-town pizza shop, the review volume and ratings are remarkable. La Bona isn’t trying to reinvent anything. It’s just doing the fundamentals better than almost anyone in the area.
Why locals love it: a near-perfect rating across every platform, and the kind of pizza that makes you stop ordering from anywhere else. It’s Old Tappan’s answer to “what’s for dinner?” at least once a week.
Hoshitori Sushi
Hoshitori has been Old Tappan’s Japanese restaurant since 2013, serving a full menu of sushi, sashimi, rolls, and traditional Japanese dishes. The fish is fresh, the presentation is clean, and the consistency over more than a decade of operation speaks to a kitchen that takes its craft seriously.
The menu covers everything from standard rolls and bento boxes to more adventurous omakase-style selections. For families in Old Tappan and surrounding communities, Hoshitori fills the essential role of a reliable neighborhood sushi spot, the kind of place you can count on for a quality meal any night of the week.
Why locals love it: over a decade of consistent, quality Japanese food right in the borough. The sushi is fresh, the menu is deep, and it’s the neighborhood’s go-to for Japanese cuisine.
Old Tappan’s Food Scene Reflects Its Community
What makes Old Tappan’s restaurant scene work is the same thing that makes the borough work: it’s diverse, quality-driven, and built for the neighbors who eat there. Mediterranean fine dining, Neapolitan family Italian, a near-perfect pizza shop, and Japanese sushi, all serving a community where 51% of residents are White and 41% are Asian. The food tells the story of who lives here, and it’s a good story.
Ready to Make Old Tappan Home?
The dining scene is only part of the picture. Old Tappan’s combination of an A+ ranked high school, near-zero crime, and one of the highest-income communities in Bergen County makes it a top-tier choice for families in the Pascack Valley. As a Bergen County real estate expert who covers all 70 municipalities, I can help you find the right home in this exceptional borough, and I’m always happy to talk through Bergen County’s other luxury towns if you’re still weighing your options. I’d be glad to help you turn your dreams into an address.
Search Old Tappan Homes for Sale | Get a Free Home Valuation | Browse All Bergen County Towns
Tom Lee | NJNest
Phone: 848-565-1425
Email: tom@njnest.com
Website: njnest.com
Tom Lee is a licensed real estate agent with 2Win Realty, specializing in Bergen County residential real estate. With deep local expertise and a client-first approach, Tom helps buyers and sellers across all 70 Bergen County municipalities make confident real estate decisions.
