Every few weeks I take a call from buyers who have spent months touring Cresskill and Demarest, love everything about the Northern Valley, and cannot make the numbers work. My answer is almost always the same. Drive one town west. Dumont sits directly against both of those boroughs, shares the same quiet tree-lined grid, and sells its homes at a price point its neighbors have not seen in years.
This is the classic starter-home borough of eastern Bergen County. Just under 18,000 people live here, most of them in capes, colonials, and split levels built in the decades after World War II. Families arrive for a first house, discover a town that shows up for its ballfields and school concerts, and quietly stop planning the next move. Here are five reasons Dumont belongs on your shortlist.
1. Starter Homes That Are Actually Attainable
Roughly six in ten Dumont homes went up between the 1940s and the 1960s, and it shows in the best way. The streets are lined with tidy capes with dormered second floors, modest colonials, and split levels on manageable lots. Redfin put the average sale price around $618,000 as of mid 2026, up about 3 percent year over year, with listing medians running in the high $600s. In Bergen County terms, that is a true entry point. These are houses a two-income young family can actually close on, in a county where the alternative is often a condo or a far longer commute. The market is competitive but not brutal, and because the housing stock is so consistent, resale is straightforward. When you buy a well-kept Dumont cape, you are buying into a proven, liquid segment of the market, not gambling on an outlier.
2. You Are Pressed Against the Northern Valley’s Priciest Borders
Pull up a map. Dumont touches Cresskill and Demarest on its eastern side, Haworth to the north, and Bergenfield and New Milford to the south and west. That location is the whole thesis. The same commuter corridors, the same county parks, the same short drive to Tenafly’s and Cresskill’s downtowns, all without the property taxes and purchase prices that come with those addresses. I have sold homes on Dumont streets where the town line runs a few hundred feet away. The maple trees do not change at the border. For buyers who want the Northern Valley lifestyle but need the mortgage to leave room for daycare and a car payment, Dumont is the honest answer, and plenty of longtime residents will tell you they stopped seeing it as a stepping stone years ago.
3. A Genuinely Tight Community With Deep Roots
Dumont was settled as Schraalenburgh, and the congregation at Old North Reformed Church on Washington Avenue organized all the way back in 1723. The current sanctuary, built in 1801, is on the National Register of Historic Places, and Revolutionary War soldiers rest in its churchyard. The borough took its modern name in 1894 in honor of Dumont Clarke, its first mayor, and during World War I much of the town sat within Camp Merritt, the great embarkation camp whose memorial was placed on the church grounds in 1919. That history matters because the town still behaves like a place with roots. This is a borough of block parties, packed rec-league bleachers, and neighbors who have known each other for twenty years. Buyers feel it within a month of moving in.
4. Schools That Outperform the Price of Entry
Here is the quiet bargain. Niche ranks the Dumont Public School District #67 among all school districts in New Jersey for 2026, and Dumont High School carries an A- overall grade with a ranking of #139 among the state’s public high schools. The high school runs a 12 to 1 student-teacher ratio, and the district serves about 2,560 students from pre-K through twelfth grade, small enough that kids do not get lost in the crowd. Plenty of Bergen County families pay double Dumont’s home prices for rankings in the same neighborhood. If your priority is a solid, well-run district attached to a house you can actually afford, this combination is hard to beat anywhere in the eastern half of the county.
5. A One-Seat Bus Ride to Midtown
Dumont commuters have a direct line to the city from their own corner. NJ Transit’s 167 route runs right through town, including stops along Washington Avenue, straight to the Port Authority Bus Terminal at 41st Street. Direct runs take roughly 45 minutes to an hour depending on the trip, with buses departing about every 30 minutes through much of the day and the 167T express variant riding I-95 to shave time at peak hours. Prefer the train? The Pascack Valley Line at New Bridge Landing in neighboring River Edge is a short drive, with service to Secaucus Junction for the transfer to Penn Station. Drivers reach Route 4 and the George Washington Bridge approaches quickly. For a town at this price point, that range of options is a legitimate advantage.
Where to Eat in Dumont
Dumont’s food scene is compact, local, and better than outsiders expect, concentrated along the Washington Avenue and Madison Avenue corridors. No velvet ropes, no scene, just kitchens that have earned their regulars. These five spots are where I send clients, and where you will find actual Dumont residents on a Friday night.
Grant Street Cafe
Serving Bergen County since 1989, Grant Street is the borough’s living room. The thin crust pizza has a countywide reputation, the mussels are famous for a reason, and the craft beer list runs deeper than any bar this size should manage. The kitchen also delivers on fresh seafood, steaks, and burgers.
It picked up honors at 201 Magazine’s Best of Bergen 2026 awards, and the dining room and bar are packed most weekends. Parking on a Saturday night is the only complaint you will hear.
Why locals love it: It is the rare neighborhood tavern where the pizza alone would justify the trip, and it has been that way for over 35 years.
La Taberna Steak & Tapas Bar
Open since 2017 on West Madison Avenue, La Taberna brings Spanish flair to a steakhouse menu. The grilled octopus comes up in nearly every review, the paella and shrimp al ajillo hold their own, and the sangria pitchers keep tables lingering.
The room turns lively on weekends with occasional live music and DJs, yet it stays family-friendly at dinner hour. For a special occasion that does not require leaving town, this is Dumont’s answer.
Why locals love it: It gives a starter-home town a legitimate date-night spot, with octopus and steaks that would hold up in Englewood or Edgewater.
Buongiorno’s Ristorante
This small Italian spot on Washington Avenue is the definition of a neighborhood red-sauce room, cozy, unpretentious, and consistent. Regulars swear by the pasta, the chicken dishes, and the pork chops, and a terrific dinner still lands around $30 a head.
It runs daily for dine-in and takeout, and the portions reflect a kitchen that thinks like a family, not a chain. Bring cash for the tip jar and an appetite.
Why locals love it: Honest Italian cooking at prices that match the town, from people who remember your order.
Thai Chef Jr
Tucked on McKinley Avenue, this takeout-focused Thai kitchen carries a 4.9 rating and reviews calling it the best Thai food its customers have found in New Jersey. It was named a Best of Bergen finalist and landed on a statewide list of top new restaurants.
Orders take a few extra minutes because everything is cooked to order, portions are generous, and the owner greets regulars by name. It is a small operation doing one thing at a very high level.
Why locals love it: Big-city Thai cooking from a tiny storefront, made by an owner who treats every order like it matters.
Jalapeño
The newest name on this list, Jalapeño opened in 2025 in the Merritt Shopping Center on East Madison Avenue and quickly built a following for fresh, made-to-order Mexican food. Tacos, burritos, and platters come out fast, and the ratings on the delivery apps have stayed north of 4.4.
It is open seven days a week with online ordering, the kind of reliable weeknight option every family needs within five minutes of home.
Why locals love it: Fresh Mexican done right in town, so taco night no longer requires a drive to Bergenfield.
What Dumont’s Food Scene Says About the Town
Notice what is missing: chains, gimmicks, and turnover. Dumont’s restaurants are owner-operated places that have either lasted decades or earned their following fast, because in a town this tight, word of mouth is the only marketing that works. That is the same reason people stay in the houses. When a community rewards consistency over flash, both the kitchens and the property values tend to hold up.
Ready to Make Dumont Home?
If you have been touring the Northern Valley and wincing at the numbers, let me show you what those same streets feel like one town west. I know which Dumont blocks border Cresskill, which capes have the good bones, and how to win a competitive offer without overpaying. Dumont rewards buyers who move with a plan, and building that plan is my job.
Search Dumont Homes for Sale | Get a Free Home Valuation | Browse All Bergen County Towns
Tom Lee | NJNest
Phone: 848-565-1425
Email: tom@njnest.com
Website: njnest.com
Tom Lee is a licensed real estate agent with 2Win Realty, specializing in Bergen County residential real estate. With deep local expertise and a client-first approach, Tom helps buyers and sellers across all 70 Bergen County municipalities make confident real estate decisions.
